Vanished without a trace during a dream getaway, Amy Bradley’s disappearance has kept the world hooked for decades. Whispers, alleged sightings, and unsettling clues have kept her story alive, yet definitive answers have remained at large. Now, a gripping new Netflix documentary, Amy Bradley Is Missing, explores the case with a chilling new theory from the makers. But is it the truth or mere speculation yet again? As the mystery deepens, viewers are left to question everything they know.

The filmmakers behind Netflix’s latest true crime documentary think they have pieced together the dark reality behind the subject's eerie vanishing.

Ari Mark and Phil Lott, who directed Amy Bradley is Missing, recently sat down with The Hollywood Reporter, where they were asked what they wished to uncover with their Netflix feature. While the duo answered the query by saying “it depends,” they did end up giving clues about what they think actually happened to Amy Bradley, who disappeared from a cruise ship in 1998 at the age of 23. While her body was never found despite extensive investigation and the case closed by concluding that she may have died after jumping or falling into the ocean, the documentary makers believe she is still alive.

Ari Mark told the outlet that he has gotten to the point where he “has to believe she is alive” and that now he does not care if people judge him for that. The filmmaker told the publication he understands if people question how he could believe in the most far-fetched aspect of the case. He said that when he tells a remarkable story, he has to hold on to the idea of the story having a “remarkable answer” as well. As THR asked both him and Phil Lott how people could deny a particular photograph of a person resembling Amy Bradley to the tee following the disappearance, Mark again reiterated how people do not believe in it just because the possibility of Bradley being alive is far-fetched. Beyond the filmmaker's point of view, how did the FBI take the photo?

'Amy Bradley is Missing' on Netflix: Top Theories That Still Haunt Investigators

One photograph raised more questions than it answered, prompting the FBI to take notice.

According to Ari Mark, the FBI took the aforementioned photograph as seriously as the makers did, as the officials really chased the clue down. The authorities, per Mark, sent operatives to the traced location to dig deeper into the matter. However, a dead end was met yet again. The picture cited by THR was positioned in a way that would hide all of Amy Bradley’s identifying marks, and that was something that raised an alarm for all parties involved.

As Amy Bradley’s case remains unresolved, the documentary can now be streamed on Netflix alongside other similar offerings in the streamer's vault. As the haunting mystery of Amy Bradley’s disappearance lingers, Amy Bradley is Missing does not offer closure, but it reignites the search for truth with a provocative theory that dares to imagine she may still be alive.

'Under a Dark Sun' on Netflix: Is the French Thriller Really Worth Watching?

What do you think about the documentary filmmakers' belief that Amy Bradley may still be alive? Share your thoughts in the comments below!