The appetite for bone-chilling true crime on Netflix is far from sated, with The Perfect Neighbor stepping into the spotlight to greet spectators of eerie tales. If Monster: The Ed Gein Story left viewers shivering under blankets, then this fresh addition promises a new kind of discomfort. This is not just another documentary; it is a slow-burn invitation into a neighborhood where things are far from perfect. Prepare to meet your next obsession.

True crime enthusiasts can brace themselves because when it came to unearthed horrors, Netflix just raised the stakes again.

Both The Perfect Neighbor and Monster: The Ed Gein Story excel at exposing the shadows lurking just beneath ordinary lives. While Ed Gein’s grisly reign is a classic horror blueprint, The Perfect Neighbor ups the stakes with a tense, simmering conflict between neighbors that turns deadly. It is less about one person’s madness and more about how a seemingly quiet community can spiral into chaos overnight. That difference alone makes it impossible to look away.

Adding to Netflix's true-crime-laden inventory following Monster: The Ed Gein Story; The Perfect Neighbor, directed by Geeta Gandbhir, dives headfirst into the 2023 murder case involving Susan Lorincz and Ajike Owens in Ocala, Florida. This documentary uses jaw-dropping police bodycam footage, stretching over a year, to reveal every heated moment and legal loophole that fueled the tragedy. It portrays a heartbreaking story tangled with systemic failures, one that will haunt viewers long after the credits roll.

Susan Lorincz’s Story ‘The Perfect Neighbor’ Documentary on Netflix: Release Date, Plot, and All About It

If you thought one monster was enough to keep you awake at night, wait until you meet the perfect neighbour from your worst nightmare.

By contrast, Monster: The Ed Gein Story dissects the life of one of America’s most infamous killers with chilling detail. Through psychological insight and crime re-creation, it traces Gein’s descent into monstrous acts that inspired horror legends. The series is a meticulously crafted horror history lesson, and a hard act to follow, but The Perfect Neighbor brings a modern twist on terror rooted in real-world complexities.

Netflix viewers craving a fresh nerve-twisting docuseries have great reasons to add The Perfect Neighbor to their watchlists. It throws down a gauntlet next to Ed Gein’s infamy with a story that feels frighteningly close to home. Whether you prefer the dark mind of one monster or the deadly drama of a neighborhood gone wrong, this pair offers a double dose of chilling entertainment.

11 Unbelievable Crime Documentaries on Netflix That Will Leave You Stunned

Will you be tuning in to watch Netflix's guide to being The Perfect Neighbor? Let us know in the comments below!