Is Argyle Returning in 'Stranger Things' Season 5? What Happened to the Season 4 MVP?

Published 11/17/2025, 1:00 PM EST

Tense air runs through the new season of Stranger Things: a showdown, new beginnings, and the feeling that nothing will be completely the same. The fifth season brings together the return of the old heroes of Hawkins, new threats, and broken alliances, all under the shadow of Upside Down, which is getting bigger and riskier. However, some fan-favorite characters might be missing from this season.

And one major name is already gaining the most attention, Jonathan Byers’ friend. Is he not going to be back one final time? 

What lies ahead for Argyle in Stranger Things Season 5?

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Argyle won people’s hearts in Season 4 with his charm and also quite surprising fidelity, the one he had to Jonathan Byers. He not only delivered pizza but also main character energy. However, his return to Season 5 is highly unlikely. Eduardo Franco, who immortalized Argyle, has clearly stated that Argyle will not appear in the fifth season. During an appearance on the Steve Varley Show, he said, "I never got a phone call. So, I think that’s it," axing all hopes of Argyle's return in the final battle on Hawkins.

Stranger Things Season 5's first cast announcement met with disappointment as the cast photo saw the notable absence of Franco, which gave birth to speculation among fans. Franco, later on, expressed his appreciation for the fans for whom Argyle was not just a comic relief, as he brought a new atmosphere to a dark and complicated season. However, he clarified that the fifth season will continue without him, like a few other important characters who had to bid goodbye. 

Does Will Byers Have a Hidden Psychic Power in 'Stranger Things 5'?

Not only Argyle, but Hawkins' growing hostile environment will be seeing the end of several other side characters.

Those departing in Stranger Things season 5

Argyle's coolness was just the right counterpoise to the horror and heaviness of Hawkins’ saga, and his being around constantly reminded the audience of the show’s core of friendship and survival. However, Hawkins has been suffering from the ramifications of Vecna's plan, and side-characters like Claudia Henderson, played by Catherine Curtin, Dmitri Antonov, played by Tom Wlaschiha, and Yuri Ismaylov, played by Nikola Duricko, seem to have no place in the story. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

As the saga concludes for one final time, the story seeks to provide complete focus on the core characters, such as Eleven, Mike, Lucas, Dustin, Max, Steve, Nancy, Jonathan, and the like. Though Argyle's disappearance from the cast list does not make for its haunting absence, it signals a shift in tone for Stranger Things Season 5, which gets closer to a darker predicament.

'Stranger Things' and Beyond: Everything the Duffer Brothers Are Building at Netflix

ADVERTISEMENT

Article continues below this ad

Will you miss Argyle in Season 5? Comment your thoughts below.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :

ADVERTISEMENT

Ipshita Chakraborty

372 articles

Ipshita Chakraborty is an entertainment writer at Netflix Junkie. Offering thoughtful and compelling storytelling, they cover everything Hollywood and trending, from the latest streaming sensations to behind-the-scenes buzz. With about 7 years of writing experience for online media, Ipshita brings their voice to the coverage through industry analysis and cultural critique, a strength evident in prior work, such as their views on why the Michaela gender swap was needed in Bridgerton.

Edited By: Hriddhi Maitra

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

EDITORS' PICK