Crime thrillers have long captivated audiences with their mix of suspense, mystery, and the kick of uncovering hidden truths. In recent years, the genre has seen a spike, with viewers immensely drawn to stories that challenge the mind and keep hearts racing. Streaming platforms, particularly Netflix, have leveraged this appetite, delivering one gripping narrative after another, with its latest being Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders, which uncovers a chilling crime case from more than four decades ago.

On a quiet fall day in the 1980s, a well-known US city went about its routine, unaware that a seemingly ordinary painkiller would soon unravel a series of deadly events. What exactly happened, though?

In September 1982, Chicago was rocked by a chilling wave of deaths that would come to be known as the Tylenol murders. Seven people, aged 12 to 35, died after taking Tylenol capsules laced with deadly cyanide. The seemingly ordinary painkiller became a symbol of terror, sparking a nationwide panic and one of the largest criminal investigations in US history. While authorities traced leads and theories, including potential factory tampering, the case remained frustratingly unresolved. Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders on Netflix explores this very account.

Netflix’s Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders, per Tudum, revisits this haunting chapter with fresh insights, combining interviews of those closest to the case, including suspect James Lewis. The docuseries examines how the tragedy reshaped consumer trust, prompting Johnson & Johnson to implement triple-layered tamper-proof seals. Despite several years gone by and multiple suspects investigated, the mystery of who deliberately poisoned the capsules lingers, making this chilling crime story as unsettling today as it was when it unfolded. And while the Tylenol case wraps up in a crisp three episodes on Netflix, the larger Cold Case franchise explores another equally chilling tale.

10 New Documentaries Streaming on Netflix in 2025 That You Need to Watch

For those interested in playing detective while binging a series, Cold Case: Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey also offers the same edge-of-the-seat experience.

In 1996, six-year-old JonBenét Ramsey was found dead in her Colorado home, sparking one of the most infamous cases in American history. The young beauty queen's mysterious demise ignited an endless media frenzy, with suspicions swirling around her family. Despite exhaustive investigations, forensic efforts, and numerous theories, the truth behind JonBenét’s death remains elusive. Her case continues to capture the public imagination as a tragic tale of lost innocence and the relentless pursuit of answers that refuse to surface.

Ultimately, series like Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders and Who Killed JonBenét Ramsey provide terrifying insights into human behavior, investigative challenges, and the enduring pursuit of justice. Beyond shock value, these stories explore the complexities behind infamous cases, offering a deeper understanding of why some files remain collecting dust. Needless to say, such series represent a valuable addition to Netflix’s expansive trove of crime dramas, enriching the platform's lineup with compelling and thought-provoking chronicles.

Is There A Movie called 'Terror Comes Knocking' on Netflix? Cast, Story, And Everything Explained

Will you soon be binge-watching the Cold Case franchise on Netflix? Let us know in the comments below.