A tux, a cold martini, and a license to kill, few cinematic icons are as lasting as James Bond. For decades, actors have strived for the chance to slip into 007’s polished shoes, hoping to leave their mark on a character defined by charm, danger, and a hint of darkness. Yet, for every Bond who graces the screen, many come close, only to watch the opportunity vanish like smoke from a Walther PPK. When asked to define the character, Matthew Goode gave a proposal so raw it ended his chances before they even began.

A single conversation can change the course of a legend, and sometimes, it is not the audition but the idea that seals a fate and for Goode, it was definitely the latter.

Matthew Goode, celebrated for his nuanced performances and British wit, found himself face-to-face with Bond producer Barbara Broccoli just as the search for a new 007 was heating up. In a recent podcast of Happy Sad Confused, he said he never had a chance to clear the audition because of his point of view on 007. In his conversation with Broccoli, Goode advocated for a darker James Bond, “A drug addict. He hates himself. He hates women. He hates a lot of people. He’s in deep pain." 

Instead of dazzling with smooth one-liners, Matthew Goode’s vision, while rooted in Ian Fleming’s original novels, was deemed too dark for the cinematic Bond, and the role slipped through his hands, never to return. Goode’s approach was not just bold, it was a gamble that risked everything on authenticity. The silence that followed in Broccoli’s office spoke volumes, and Goode soon realized his vision was a step too far for the franchise.

“It’s the curse”- Matthew Goode Gets Brutally Honest About the Dark Side of Success in Hollywood

Matthew Goode’s bold take became an industry tale, a reminder that sometimes, the doors to MI6 close not with a bang, but with the quiet certainty of a single fateful meeting.

After the meeting, Matthew Goode reflected on his approach with a mix of humor and humility. He admitted that his take on James Bond was perhaps too intense for the producers’ vision and probably ruffled up Barbara Broccoli's feathers. He later realized that he had overlooked the importance of Bond’s charm, a key ingredient that has defined the character for generations.

Matthew Goode’s near-miss with Bond has become part of the lore surrounding the world’s most famous spy. While Goode did not become 007, his vision lingers as a tantalizing what-if in the Bond universe. As Amazon continues the search for the next James Bond, Goode’s story stands as both a cautionary tale and an inspiration.

“You would not believe that I beat...”- Matthew Goode Reflects on Landing Major Role Over Big Stars

Do you think Matthew Goode would have been justified as 007 if Barbara Broccoli had agreed to his idea? Let us know in the comments below.